Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Technical questions and answers concerning all models of VW diesel vehicles.

Moderator: Fatmobile

Clydesdale
Glow Plug
Posts: 15
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2006 8:15 pm
Location: Rockville, Maryland

Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by Clydesdale »

Hi All,

I just went through a full engine rebuild with my 81 Rabbit pickup and after 10,000 miles I have a leaking head gasket (water seeping out of it). Is there a thread that has everything to do to virtually guarantee that the head gasket will last a LONG time? I'm guessing that they should last a while as VW probably wasn't swamped with head gasket warranty issues.

Here are my engine details:

1: Rebuilt 1.6D (with 12 mm head bolts)
2: I used ARP head studs (torqued as recommended to 90 ft lbs, I believe)
3: Rebuilt injection pump (works great but had to tweak the "smoke screw" to make the car move - NO power at all on delivered setting)
4: Rebuild head. This was an 11mm head that I had the head bolt holes enlarged. Mistake? Should I have just found a 12mm head and had it rebuilt?
5: Timing set to I believe about .95 (for power, rather than economy, I read in different places, I think even on this site)

The engine runs great. The temperature gauge was rock solid in the middle until a few weeks ago (about 10K miles). Then it went up one tick mark just as the head gasket started leaking (I'm guessing hot gasses from the cylinder into the water, heating it up). I drive it fairly hard on the interstate (70 mph) but don't flog it getting up to speed or around town.

I'm assuming that the engine/head rebuild shop checked for a warped head and block as they specialize in VW diesels. I didn't do it.

I'm planning on replacing the head gasket but want this one to last (as, of course, I wanted the current one but with no luck).

Any tips will be greatly appreciated.

Steve
Last edited by Clydesdale on Thu Jan 08, 2015 2:27 pm, edited 4 times in total.
TylerDurden
Turbo Charger
Posts: 1285
Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 1:01 pm
Location: Michigami, USA

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by TylerDurden »

I'd use hylomar gasket sealant on the next.

What rpm at 70mph? (or tranny code and tire size)
Have a nice day.


'91 Jetta ECOdiesel TD - clean & complete (less motor/tranny) for sale

'82 Westy Vanagon 1.9 N/A - 23.5mpg
'86 Jetta TD - 45-50mpg
'81 Dasher Wagon 1.6 N/A - 52mpg
'84 Wasserboxer - DOA, parts donor
'94 Passat wagon VR6
'03 Jetta TDI wagon 230K, 52.3mpg
'89 Jetta N/A - 51mpg
'82 Caddy 1.6 N/A - Sold
82vdub
Turbo Charger
Posts: 4922
Joined: Wed Jun 20, 2007 1:44 pm
Location: Green Bay, WI
Contact:

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by 82vdub »

I've never used sealant when I've done the head gaskets. Not saying that it shouldnt' be used though.

There's a test kit that you can do to see if you are getting combustion gasses into the coolant. I'd test this first before replacing the head gasket if the water leak isn't excessive. Ole 82 has the typical corner weaping coolant issue and no issues with getting combustion gasses or oil into the coolant. This is a common problem on these engines, although one would expect that after 10k miles it wouldn't leak, but that has happened to me before, but for me the coolant leak isn't enough to worry much yet about it yet, as long as oil isn't getting into the coolant either.

Did you retorque the head studs? I did studs on mine (11mm) when I last did the head gasket and when I checked a year later (That's when my head gasket started to leak), the stud nuts weren't as torqued as I would have expected them to be. I'm going to redo the belt this spring, so it will be interesting to see how tight they are after another 2 years of use on it since it was last checked.
Everybody else lists their cars here - but not me.

I have too many to count
Clydesdale
Glow Plug
Posts: 15
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2006 8:15 pm
Location: Rockville, Maryland

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by Clydesdale »

TylerDurden wrote:I'd use hylomar gasket sealant on the next.

What rpm at 70mph? (or tranny code and tire size)
I don't have a tach on the care but it has the 5 speed, 020, FN transmission so I think the engine is not over-reved at 70mph.

I'll look into the gasket sealer. Thanks.

Steve
Clydesdale
Glow Plug
Posts: 15
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2006 8:15 pm
Location: Rockville, Maryland

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by Clydesdale »

82vdub wrote:I've never used sealant when I've done the head gaskets. Not saying that it shouldnt' be used though.

There's a test kit that you can do to see if you are getting combustion gasses into the coolant. I'd test this first before replacing the head gasket if the water leak isn't excessive. Ole 82 has the typical corner weaping coolant issue and no issues with getting combustion gasses or oil into the coolant. This is a common problem on these engines, although one would expect that after 10k miles it wouldn't leak, but that has happened to me before, but for me the coolant leak isn't enough to worry much yet about it yet, as long as oil isn't getting into the coolant either.

Did you retorque the head studs? I did studs on mine (11mm) when I last did the head gasket and when I checked a year later (That's when my head gasket started to leak), the stud nuts weren't as torqued as I would have expected them to be. I'm going to redo the belt this spring, so it will be interesting to see how tight they are after another 2 years of use on it since it was last checked.
Great input. Thanks.

I haven't done a real coolant/exhaust gas test. I probably should. I did the "glove test" where I put a very thin rubber glove over the overflow tank opening after letting the car sit overnight. After a few minutes of running the glove didn't inflate that I could tell so I guess there isn't much exhaust going into the cooling system. Maybe a tiny amount. Maybe I should try this after the engine warms up (parts expanded, possibly breaking a good head gasket seal).

I re-torqued the head studs a week or so after getting the engine running about 9 months ago. One or two were pretty far off, it seemed (turned almost 1/2 turn before the wrench clicked). I just checked/re-torqued the head by setting the torque to 94 - maybe a bad thing (over-torquing?) - but within 5% of recommended. All stud nuts went a very small amount, maybe 5 degrees, before the torque wrench click. All were fairly consistent, which I guess is a good sign since they were not when I re-torqued just after getting it running..

I never heard of the corners seeping. That seems to be what I have as this seems to be the two front corners. Although it is interesting that my temperature gauge went up by 1 tick mark at about the time when the seeping started. Maybe a it's coincidence. Maybe the change in weather from warm to bitterly cold?

Fortunately (so far!) there is no oil in the coolant. I've been through that nightmare once. Apparently I bought the car with a rebuilt engine - that had a cracked block (that the VW mechanic who sold the car to me "forgot" to tell me about). Oil was going into the coolant pretty badly. I had to trash that block (an 11mm block, BTW).

So, and I'd really HATE to do this to a completely new/rebuilt system (engine, head, radiator and hoses) if there is no exhaust in the coolant maybe I can "fix" this with radiator sealant? That will be my very last resort if at all. Things simply shouldn't leak where they need an additional additive sealant.

Steve
82vdub
Turbo Charger
Posts: 4922
Joined: Wed Jun 20, 2007 1:44 pm
Location: Green Bay, WI
Contact:

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by 82vdub »

I've noticed over the years that on Ole 82 when it gets cold and you turn up the temp gauge and start sending coolant through the heater core, that the temp gauge rises a bit. There must be enough of a difference in circulation where this changes the gauge, but I never looked further into it than that.
Everybody else lists their cars here - but not me.

I have too many to count
Quantum-man
Turbo Charger
Posts: 2085
Joined: Mon Apr 24, 2006 4:34 pm
Location: Gloucester; Limey-Land

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by Quantum-man »

Get an original asbestos gasket.
In general: [My personal findings]
Periodically revisiting the head bolts is good policy, retorque those that undo with a torque of 60lbft or less. If bolt doesn't shift at say 70lbft, then leave alone. Retorque to 95lbft those that are 'loose'.
"I'm not here to help... I'm here to Pro-Volke"

Be like meeee...Drive a Quantum TD
...The best work-horse after the cart...

Quantae grow on you...but Rabbits are like roses...
... girls like em ;o)

Only one Darwin, Einstein, Poe and Verne.
That is why if you listen, you will learn:
From the one and only Quantum-man,
Who sees the worms from outside of the can.

7 Quantae in 20 years; 4 dead and 3 TD's still alive [2 wagons & 1 fastback] oh and a GTD :o)
Clydesdale
Glow Plug
Posts: 15
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2006 8:15 pm
Location: Rockville, Maryland

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by Clydesdale »

Quantum-man wrote:Get an original asbestos gasket.
In general: [My personal findings]
Periodically revisiting the head bolts is good policy, retorque those that undo with a torque of 60lbft or less. If bolt doesn't shift at say 70lbft, then leave alone. Retorque to 95lbft those that are 'loose'.
I didn't know that there was such a thing as an asbestos gasket. You mean head gasket, correct, not the other gaskets?
surfcam
Turbo Charger
Posts: 1482
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 8:43 pm
Location: Canada Southern Alberta
Contact:

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by surfcam »

Maybe 25 to 30 years ago? Just about any paper gasket had asbestos in it. Along with brake pads and pipe insulation to name just few of the asbestos products. These gaskets were superior to other gaskets because of the long strands that asbestos has. The limey reuses heat shields so I would doubt that he has asbestos head gaskets. But how dryed out are they.
As far as head gaskets go I think I would look into the 1.9TD AZZ metal gasket or TDI Z1/AHU gasket. These engines have a very similar block to the 1.6 just a longer stroke. The AZZ gasket is reuseable. These engine just about never blow head gaskets, not unless they are over heated or crack the block. I don't know how thick they are or if they will work.
99 TDI Jetta (Z1 engine code)
94 Grand Caravan
89 Dodge Gold Stream B class
http://www.antiquedollhouseofpatterns.ca/
Quantum-man
Turbo Charger
Posts: 2085
Joined: Mon Apr 24, 2006 4:34 pm
Location: Gloucester; Limey-Land

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by Quantum-man »

It just happens that I came across a handful of Goetz asbestos headgaskets sealed in their thick plastic bags!

I think the only possible drawback of the metal gaskets, is that they are less forgiving for old, lightly corroded heads.
Whereas, the old gaskets with asbestos used to bond to the head and block, making them single use.
Perhaps Copper Coat might change this.

Modern gaskets are reusable if not corroded, and over crushed, as they remain 'plastic'.

I am indeed an, if not 'the' authority on multiple use of heatshields, and headbolts :lol:
"I'm not here to help... I'm here to Pro-Volke"

Be like meeee...Drive a Quantum TD
...The best work-horse after the cart...

Quantae grow on you...but Rabbits are like roses...
... girls like em ;o)

Only one Darwin, Einstein, Poe and Verne.
That is why if you listen, you will learn:
From the one and only Quantum-man,
Who sees the worms from outside of the can.

7 Quantae in 20 years; 4 dead and 3 TD's still alive [2 wagons & 1 fastback] oh and a GTD :o)
surfcam
Turbo Charger
Posts: 1482
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 8:43 pm
Location: Canada Southern Alberta
Contact:

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by surfcam »

I think the problem with fiber gasket is that they compress quite a bit. Metal gaskets don't need re-torquing. The fiber gasket Achilles heel is over torquing in my opinion. If you crush down too much around the studs it will end up getting pried up in the very center between the two studs. If you're careful with these gaskets there's no problem. The metal gaskets probably need closer specs. Here's one thread on it below.

http://www.vwdiesel.net/forum/index.php?topic=30521.0
99 TDI Jetta (Z1 engine code)
94 Grand Caravan
89 Dodge Gold Stream B class
http://www.antiquedollhouseofpatterns.ca/
82vdub
Turbo Charger
Posts: 4922
Joined: Wed Jun 20, 2007 1:44 pm
Location: Green Bay, WI
Contact:

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by 82vdub »

Speaking from knowledge of old GM engines (specifically Chevy), they used to use steel shim head gaskets as the block and head were all new and within tolerance to spec where just a thin piece of metal would seal things. The composite gaskets came about because over time blocks and heads warp a little, where something that will absorb a little variation in flatness probably came about after many issues with the shim type gaskets. I've even heard that some new engines (not specifically head gaskets) have such tight machine tolerances that some parts or pieces are assembled without any gasket in them.
Everybody else lists their cars here - but not me.

I have too many to count
surfcam
Turbo Charger
Posts: 1482
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 8:43 pm
Location: Canada Southern Alberta
Contact:

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by surfcam »

I owned a 500 single 1952 Ariel Red Hunter. No gaskets. What a leakier. These machines were put together by Fitters. There's millions of them that live in the UK. They still building the Rolls Royce cars by hand.(maybe vw bought it can remember). Their's an company that builds handmade ball bears over there.
99 TDI Jetta (Z1 engine code)
94 Grand Caravan
89 Dodge Gold Stream B class
http://www.antiquedollhouseofpatterns.ca/
greg lousy
Turbo Charger
Posts: 230
Joined: Thu Apr 05, 2012 12:22 am
Location: Rhode Island

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by greg lousy »

Whats the consensus on copper spray? I like it, but I've only done two of these jobs and my preference could very well be in my head.
Various vehicles in various states
Fatmobile
Global Moderator
Posts: 7564
Joined: Wed Oct 30, 2002 10:28 pm
Location: north central Iowa

Re: Tips for a fail-proof head gasket - Any such thing???

Post by Fatmobile »

I like the copper spray.
Because the oil pressure passageway is so close to the front of the block and sometimes it seeps,.. and extra help might stop it.
I haven't had a problem with any engine I've used it on.
'91 Golf gasser converted to a 12mm pump, M-TDI.
'84 1.6TD Rabbit with a VNT-15 turbo, still setup to run on vegetable oil.
'84 GTI with 1.7TD pistons and intercooled.
2003 TDI wagon
2000 TDI Jetta.
Post Reply